Document Type: Original Article

Authors

1 Department of law, Payame Noor University, Tehran

2 LL. B., LL.M (Family Law)(Lond.), M.A. Mat. Can. Law (Melit.) LL.D, Advocate, Malta

Abstract

The tendency to beauty is an intrinsic and natural desire and quest of every human-being. According to the history, surgery to improve one’s looks existed in Alexandria and in ancient Rome. Considering the developments and expansions made in the meaning of ''Disease'', the psychiatrists and knowledgeable people at that time, started to declare that the person’s physical defects were a reflection of an inner mental disorder , thus physical features which did not meet a certain degree of perfection were seen as a kind of disease and consequently cosmetic surgical operations aimed at reflecting inner beauty, in this case, mental beauty were seen as the only kind of treatment of this disease.  The main doubts regarding the legality of cosmetic surgeries were removed by considering the aim of the treatment of these kinds of surgeries and also the contemporary theories in authorization of surgeries aimed at improving one’s looks, so that cosmetic surgeries now are considered legal and lawful. Although in most legal systems as well as in Islamic countries, the nature of medical obligations is the obligation to the means, however in some special cases, the nature of medical obligations is the obligation to the results. In the Iranian's legal system, the nature of surgeons’ obligations has been introduced as the obligation to the results which seems reasonable and logical. So in this article, with a brief description of the history of the subject and the views of proponents and opponents, the nature of surgeons obligations it's been tried to comparatively study. An analytical investigation of the nature of the obligations of the surgeons has been dealt with in some controversial, common and related instances, i.e cosmetic and/or plastic surgery.

Keywords

Salehi H.R. (2011). Cosmetic surgery, necessity or excess? A reference to nature of obligations of cosmetic surgeons. Quarterly journal of medical law, 5(18):97-116

Mémeteau, G. Cours de droit médical, Les études Hospitalières (2001). Bordeaux: Edition 38.

Mohseni MA. Fiqh & medicines matters. (2003). 1st edn. Qom: Boostane Ketabe Qom press.

Lehv, M.S. (2007). ‘Liability of Plastic Surgeons’ in Shafeek Sandy Sanbar (ed.), Legal Medicine, Mosby Elsevier, Philadelphia, 481-482.

Jackson, E. Medical L. (2006).  Text, Cases and Materials, OUP, 105.

Penneau, J. La responsabilité du médecin (1996). 2e édition, Paris: Dalloz press.

Nys, H. (1997). Medical Law in Belgium, Kluwer Law International, London.

Kennedy I., Grubb, A. (1998). Principle of medical law, New York: Oxford University Press.

Salehi H.R., Fallah M.R., Abbasi M. (2010). Comparative study of the nature of the obligation of the owners of medical and dependent. Quarterly journal of medical law. 4(14):131-152

Flour, Aubert, Savaux. Droit civil, les obligations, l'acte juridique, 10e édition, Armand colin, Paris. 

Katouzian N. (2008). Civil liability, General principles. T1. 8 edn. Tehran: Tehran university press.

Katouzian N. (2006). Course of civil law. T 4. 5th edn. Tehran: Sahami Enteshar Publication.

Shahidi M. (2007). The effects of contracts & obligations. 3rd edn. Tehran: Majd publication.

Salehi H.R., Abbasi M. (2011). Analyze of the nature of medical obligations and their examples with comparative study. Quarterly journal of medical law. 5(16):39-58

Shojapourian S. (2010). Physician's contractual responsibility toward patient. First edn. Tehran: Ferdowsi publication.

Cyril C. (2001). La responsabilité du fait de la missionne soins des établissements  publics et privé de santé, les études hospitalières  édition.

Charles B. M. (2003). Dangers of modern medicine. Siahate Gharb review, 6:82-89

Ossoukine A. (2003). Traité de droit médical, Publication du laboratoire de recherche sur le droit et les nouvelles technologies.

Shokramraji A., Abbasi M. (2008). Civil responsability due to reconstructive and plastic surgery. Quarterly journal of medical law, 4:13-47.

Harichaux Ramu M. (1993). La responsabilité du médecin, Jurise classeur civil, responsabilité civil, fascicule 440_2, Article 1382 a 1386, édition technique.

Ben Chabane H. (1995). Le contrat médical met à la charge du médecin une obligation de moyen ou de résultat, Revue Algérienne des sciences juridiques économiques et politiques, n˚ 4, Volume 33. 1995

Alfazl M. (1999). Medical Liability in plastic surgery. Oman: Daralthagaffah for publication and distribution. 1995 

Dardour, J.C. (1999). Les tabous du corps, la chirurgie au secours de l'esthétique, Grancher, éd.

Koubrin S. (2000). The other side of the coin of Synthetic Cosmetic Surgery. Siahate Gharb review. 62:110-116

Koungard Black J. (2003). Does artificial beauty will shape the new feminism?. Siahate Gharb review. 53:10-13

Alamdar Saravi M., Ghalebandi M.F. (2004). Candidates personality of the cosmetic surgery. Tought & behaviour review, 4:11-17  

Ghalebandi M.F., Afkham Ebrahimi A. (2004). Applicants personality patterns of Rhinoplasty. Tought & Behaviour Review, 4.

Rohani M. (2000). Comparing the characteristics referred to the ENT clinic of Amir Alam hospital for rhinoplasty surgery Based on personality questionnaire MMPI. PhD thesis in Medicine. Tehran University of Medical Sciences and Health Services.

Ourfali S. (1984). Discuss about the responsibility of the physician in plastic surgery. Journal of the Judges Association.

Qezmar N.M. (2011). Plastic surgery, legitimate and legal aspects. 1st edn. Oman: Daralthagaffh for publication and distribution.

Mohaghegh Damad S.M. (2010). Medical Fiqh. 1st edn. Tehran: Legal publication.

 orney, M. (2007). ‘Medical Liability in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery’, in Siemonow, M.Z, and Eisenmann-Klein, M. (2007). (eds) Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Springer, 37.

Lehv, M.S. (2007). ‘Liability of Plastic Surgeons’ in Shafeek Sandy Sanbar (ed.), Legal Medicine, Mosby Elsevier, Philadelphia, 482.

Mangion, A.M. (2010). ‘Informed Consent on Treatment’, The Times of Malta, 31 December.